10th Grade Students Earn Highest Ranking of 7.5
When we released CM Country Rankings last winter, a whole new dynamic was added to Civic Mirror: students could see how good or bad the results of their collective efforts were. Just like the U.N. Human Development Index does for countries in the real world, a social studies class playing Civic Mirror can see how well their country is doing compared to other classes across the world. And while classes of students can always create their own mini-competitions with CM Tournaments, the CM Team likes to keep tabs on what countries are doing the best (and worst) overall.
We are happy to announce that Blackrock, a 10th Grade Civics class from Oakville Trafalgar High School in Oakville, Ontario earned the highest ranking in CM World in 2014/15 with a 7.5/10!!!
Criteria for Consideration
In order for countries to be considered eligible for the Country of the Year Competition, they must have met the following two criteria:
- Completed at least 1 simulated year
- Their instructor cannot have modified the simulated scenario enough to lower its “Authenticity Score” below an 8/10 (see inside civicmirror.com for details).
How Did Blackrock Do It?
Led by their stellar teacher, Mr. Michael Fraser, Blackrock’s score of 7.5 country was hard earned. In a 10-week course, he was able to navigate his students through 3 simulated years, giving them enough time to develop their economy to the point that they did well on several metrics… Notably the Mortality Rate in which they scored 10/10 for there not being a single CM Family death in their final year.
Let’s take a look at their breakdown:

Blackrock’s population was 178, which means that the class size was relatively small at around 22-24 students. This helps scores on some metrics (e.g. equality), and makes scoring well on others more difficult (e.g. GDP).
As mentioned, you can see their mortality score is 10/10 which hugely helped their overall score.
Their Literacy rate was 7.1% and their Health Care Access rate was 5.8. These are indicative of a developing country on the verge of becoming developed.
Their equality score is quite good at 8.7/10, which measures the standard deviations of housing standards, material wealth, and overall well-being.
Their Well-Being and GDP scores were 6/10, also indicative of a developing economy on its way up, but its Security score (which measures citizen access to police and protection services) was only 5/10.
Lastly, it’s Environment score was 8.5/10, which indicates that they did develop some of their Wilderness hexes in order to develop the economy, but not at a reckless rate. The blue checkmark shows that their simulated scenario was left “Authentic” and 10/10 (some teachers like to change the scenario for a variety of purposes, but this can give their countries unfair playing advantages).
Highlights from Blackrock
This is Blackrock’s national animal, a Liger. Maybe its magic skills helped the country out!?

This was one of their more interesting discussion forum posts:

Civic Mirror not only teaches students about their political, legal, and economic systems, but – almost more importantly – it provides them with opportunities to learn important life-lessons that don’t come without personal challenge.
Good News for Everyone
Oh Yes, It’s True.

Every participants’ actions have effects on the nation’s overall score. This is huge! For example, if Joffrey lived in a country within minimal food and chose to consume 3 food units because he wants to score the added Well-Being Points (he only needs 1 to keep his family alive), two of his classmate’s simulated family members would die due to starvation. Up until now in Civic Mirror, Jofffrey’s only concern would be whether or not someone would sue or criminally prosecute him. But NOW, with Country Rankings and Tournaments (more on tournaments below), his actions will directly worsen his country’s National Score, specifically in this case, the mortality rate.
Civic Mirror Tournaments
In the picturesque hamlet of Mountain View, Alberta, situated on the vast prairies and on the footsteps of the Rocky Mountains, Mr. Jamie Quinton surprised his students by bringing in a real life auctioneer for the
In the process of seeking user feedback for our
The National Scorecard
Country Scorecards and Rankings will also allow educators to facilitate inter-country competitions. For example, if 3 or 4 teachers in a school (or district, or state) all run Civic Mirror at the same time, they could use the Country Scorecard results as the basis for a class tournament: “What country will finish with the highest /10 score?”
While best known as the lead actor in movies like Jaws and Mr. Holland’s Opus, Richard Dreyfuss has been working to improve civic education for well over a decade. And we’re not talking just TV interviews here… Dreyfuss has founded
It’s emails from teachers and students like this one, from Mr. Jim Heitoff at 
Subject: Reminder
In Civic Mirror students elect classmates as politicians, and these politicians have the power to pass laws using the 3-reading legislative process. What’s great, though, is it’s up to students to enforce them… and often times they don’t. The exchange below highlights this element, but we never found out what came of it
Dianne, I am messaging you this regarding about what happened in Civic Mirror because I can type my thoughts much better than speak them. I am not here to apologize but if you think that what I did was wrong, here me out at least. Let’s start from the beginning. When you were gone, the class sat in a circle ( Town Hall) and discussed about what was going on with our Country such as lack of food and shelter. One topic came up was by Frank regarding how he needed one more Energy unit so he may be able to build other Energy Hex. Jennifer and Ali did not agree with him but at the same time, they didn’t say anything about you to keep the E.I hex. What they said was that you were corrupt because they believe you needed the Energy unit for well being points and to keep yourself alive rather than keeping our whole country alive. They did have a point but knowing Jennifer and Ali, they just wanted power. During homeroom, Ali knew I went on your account, he told me to use the Energy unit on your building but instead, I gave it to Frank. This is where everything gets complicated.
Okay Sonny, for food I say we both charge 1000, because the government cant do anything since the court round is over, and trading ends on sunday so EVERYONE needs food. But you will sell it for 1000, and you sell it for 1100 so when your supply is done, people will pay MORE… 